
by Johnny Zokovitch
Preaching in so many churches is so often disappointing that when I hear a good homily, I almost want to stand up and cheer. Such was the occasion this past weekend.
I’m fortunate to belong to a Catholic church where our retired pastor (and current priest-in-residence), Fr. Jack Schuler, regularly engages the community with sermons that highlight the social dimension of the readings of that Sunday. No soft spiritualizing of the radical message of Jesus robbing the gospel of the power to provoke and challenge us. No dime store psychologizing that makes our faith an individualistic exercise of our personal history and our inner life. Jack gets that Jesus’s words, actions, life and death have the power to turn over the tables of our economic, political, religious and cultural systems.
So, after having heard the parable of the talents in Matthew’s gospel (25:14-30) preached on dozens of times in Catholic churches throughout the United States, I was thrilled as to where Jack was going when he began with an opening disclaimer.
He started by sharing that he imagined all of us have heard this passage addressed as an allegory, with God as the master who entrusts significant amounts of money to various servants before leaving on a journey, then rewarding those who invested the money and added to his wealth, while berating and casting out the servant who buried the money in the ground. Jack noted that what we usually get in a sermon on this passage is some message about taking the “talents” that God gives us and growing them, not wasting them, like the last servant did. In other words, don’t be like the last servant.
Then Jack flipped it all on its head, smashed the allegory, and said what this parable actually does is pull back the curtain on the exploitation of capitalism and what happens to those who dare to go against such a system. In his telling, the master and the first two servants are all the beneficiaries of a system that awards the few while relegating the many to lives of desperation and fragility. Those that have, as the parable explains, get more; while those who have-not, get even what little they have taken away from them. It is the third servant who is the real hero of the parable. He accurately calls out the master as one who “[harvests] where he does not plant, and [gathers] where he does not scatter” – the ancient version of robber barons, vulture capitalists, and our current techno-feudalist oligarchs.
The third servant, in burying the money in the ground, is refusing to go along with the whole corrupt, exploitative system. And, Jack went on to say, his reward is the same that all those who stand up to such unjust systems get: he’s harassed and banished. Jack’s sermon went on to hold up the example of prophetic figures, like Rutilio Grande, who met a similar fate as the third servant when they stood up and refused to participate in corrupt and unjust systems. And he stated that we too are invited to be like the third servant.
But my delight over Jack’s demonstration of how Jesus’s parable was a critique of capitalism was doubled when I read the reflection in our bulletin. Our church invites lay people and women religious to join in our communal conversation on the Sunday readings by printing a reflection each week in that Sunday’s bulletin. And one of our community members, David Gaillardetz, must have been sharing one mind with Jack this week.
“On its surface, the ‘Parable of the Talents’ seems to essentially lionize unfettered capitalism and those who exploit others for their own gain,” David begins. “But remember that Jesus himself was raised in a society of great exploitation, one that is not hard for us to imagine. A billionaire CEO demands his underpaid staff go out and make a profit for him, at all costs. Two follow along and use predatory loans and other forms of exploitation to earn their boss a profit; one stands up and refuses to participate…Perhaps the real talent this third man had fostered was the gift of courageous voice in the face of exploitation and adversity — no matter the great personal risk.”
This, my friends, is that preaching that Archbishop Oscar Romero himself cried out for from our church.
“A church that doesn’t provoke any crisis, a gospel that doesn’t unsettle, a word of God that doesn’t get under anyone’s skin, a word of God that doesn’t touch the real sin of the society in which it is being proclaimed — what gospel is that? Very nice, pious considerations that don’t bother anyone, that’s the way many would like preaching to be.” (emphasis mine)
May our churches be blessed by bold, provocative preachers – men and women, lay, religious and ordained – who are not trapped by the “nice, pious” interpretations of Jesus’s words that generations of Catholics have become accustomed to.
Johnny Zokovitch is the former executive director of Pax Christi USA. He currently serves on the board of the Pax Christi International Fund for Peace and is in pastoral leadership at St. Cronan Catholic Church in St. Louis. Read more from Johnny at https://johnnyzokovitch.substack.com/ and sign up there to receive his articles directly to your email inbox.

Excellent analysis. Thanks.