In December 2024, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) published “Translate Hate: The Catholic edition,” an amended version of the American Jewish Committee (AJC)’s glossary of antisemitic terms, themes, and memes.
After reviewing “Translate Hate,” Kairos Palestine, an ecumenical movement of Palestinian Christians, wrote the following letter to Archbishop Timothy Broglio (Archdiocese for the Military Services), who is the current president of the USCCB, with copies sent to other leaders within the USCCB; Cardinal Pietro Parolin (the Vatican’s Secretary of State); Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa of the Patriarchate of Jerusalem; and Bishop John Stowe, bishop president of Pax Christi USA, plus several other leaders.
With heartfelt thanks to God for the recovery of His Holiness Pope Francis, we, Kairos Palestine; Palestinian Christian clergy and community leaders of all Churches in Jerusalem, address you with deep sorrow and urgency regarding the US Conference of Catholic Bishops’ (USCCB) joint resource with the American Jewish Committee’s “Translate Hate document.” This decision comes at a time of immense suffering for our people, as tens of thousands are being killed, starved, and displaced under Israel’s genocidal war on Gaza and the West Bank including East Jerusalem — actions condemned by leading international and Israeli human rights organizations.
It has also been adopted without any form of consultation with Palestinian Christians, rendering us invisible and nonexistent in a discourse that directly impacts our lives and communities. The document’s failure to address hate speech propagated on the Israeli side renders it fundamentally biased, effectively turning it into a form of hate speech against Palestinians.
As followers of our Lord Jesus Christ, we are called to speak truth to power and stand for justice. Jesus Himself declared, “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they shall be filled” (Matthew 5:6). This document misrepresents our struggle and seeks to silence voices advocating for truth and justice in the Holy Land. It negates also the immense injustices inflicted upon Palestinians, including the indigenous Christian community whose presence in the Holy Land is on the verge of extinction.
It is essential to affirm that our criticisms of Israel’s policies and the actions of its leaders are not directed at Jewish communities or Judaism itself. Israel and its policies must not be conflated with Jewish identity, and our call for accountability is not an expression of antisemitism. Rather, it is a moral and just demand for peace, security, and dignity — for Palestinians and for Jewish communities alike. True justice does not come at the expense of one people over another but ensures the safety and rights of all. In this context, adopting the Jerusalem Declaration or the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism is highly problematic, as the IHRA’s definition dangerously equates Zionism with Judaism – despite the fact that thousands of Jews around the world reject Zionism as a political ideology.
The document claims that accusations of settler colonialism and ethnic cleansing in Palestine are “categorically false,” disregarding overwhelming evidence from organizations such as Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, B’Tselem and many Israeli historians, even many early Zionist figures such as Ze’ev Jabotinsky. It equates Palestinian resistance with antisemitism, a dangerous conflation that distorts reality and undermines legitimate criticism of Israeli racist laws and policies. We categorically reject all forms of antisemitism, just as we reject any attempt to use this charge to justify oppression and to criminalize our legitimate struggle for our basic rights and our right for self-determination.
Furthermore, the document’s selective portrayal of history omits the staggering Palestinian casualties in Israel’s wars against our people in their quest for freedom. Most egregiously, it ignores the current devastation in Gaza, where entire families — our families — have perished, and where churches sheltering the innocent have not been spared Israeli bombardment. Even Pope Francis has condemned this cruelty, lamenting, “So much cruelty. Children machine-gunned, schools and hospitals bombed.”
By partnering in this document, the USCCB has alienated the indigenous Christians of the Holy Land, causing deep pain to a community struggling for survival. Ignoring their unalienable rights to live in their ancestral homeland and offering the State of Israel a justification for their forced displacement by considering their human and national rights as blood libels, only deepens this harm. We urge you to reconsider your stance and retract this endorsement. We need the Church’s voice to stand with justice and truth, not with narratives that conceal suffering and excuse oppression.
The letter was signed by 16 Palestinian Christian leaders, starting with His Beatitude Michel Sabbah, Latin Patriarch Emeritus and former co-president of Pax Christi International.
“Pax Christi USA supports our colleagues with Kairos Palestine,” said Charlene Howard, Executive Director of Pax Christi USA. “Their thoughtful reflections on the ‘Translate Hate’ document are necessary in order to help shape the Catholic collective conscience.
“We are reminded that the power of life and death is in the tongue – words have power – therefore it is the responsibility of our Church’s leadership to make every effort to ensure that people of faith have clear and accurate terms with which to write, understand and act that promote dignity and life.
“For this to happen, all of those who have been impacted by the profound violence, oppression, and inhumane actions in Palestine and Israel must be recognized in the description of terms that are used to translate hate into love.”
Read: Pax Christi International stands with Kairos Palestine
The USCCB has abdigated its responsibility and position as a religious body representing the Roman Catholic Church in the US.
The USCCB has become the American Catholic arm of the Republican Party.
This has sadly become obvious to the many Roman Catholic faithful throughout the US and has to many no longer actively participating in the Church.
We pray daily for the members of the USCCB that God, in his merciful love and kindness, will restore their hearts and their faith so as to bring them back to the teachings of the holy Roman Catholic Church.
It is happening world wide I think as the Australian Bishops are silent about the genocide in Gaza or any other matter of significance.
Thank you. 🙏🙏
The publication of the Kairos Palestine letter underscores both the honesty and courage of Pax Christi USA in these present moments of diarrhetic fear and intimidation. Accordingly, one hopes that anyone commenting on this letter has carefully read the linked “Translate Hate: The Catholic Edition.” While both the original “Translate Hate” and its Catholic commentary make for fascinating reading from an historic-linguistic point of view, clearly the document more precisely reflects Jewish trauma on the one hand and Catholic guilt on the other. Stated bluntly, the Catholic Church throughout the ages has been designated as anti-Jewish by both Jews and non-Jews for both valid and malicious reasons, in some instances with a total disregard to historical fact since in the Middle Ages Christianity and Catholicism were synonymous. Not surprisingly, our enlightened brothers of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), under the tutelage of the archbishop for Military Services, with adolescent glee leaped upon the endorsement of this document that virtually any group of people could jolly well apply to themselves. Alas, what shrieks from the pages of Translate Hate is the absolute erasing of Palestinians by our eminences whom their government and that of Israel have run through a human meat grinder.
David-Ross Gerling, PhD
It is heartbreaking to see the USCCB failing to recognize what is truly happening in the Holy Land and to fail to see the difference in being antisemitic and the cruel injustice of the Jewish government that has allowed the destruction of so many of the Palestinian people for years in that land. The horror done to the Jews during the Holocaust has been perpetrated in these recent years on the Palestinian people…as settlers have continued to steal land and destroy crops of those living in various areas of the country. I have personally witnessed the injustices on visits to the Holy Land…in times when Hebron was under siege by Israel. So many there on both sides continue to work for peace and a two state solution…the only answer to this terror and heartache, death and destruction. All the people need leaders who will find ways for this to happen and very soon. The present Government in Israel and in the US don’t seem to see this reality! And to see our church leaders comply with this understanding only continues to hatred and death!