Site icon Pax Christi USA

REFLECTION: The Catholic story, conservative vs. progressive

by Thomas Reese, S.J., NCR

Ross Douthat is a thoughtful and articulate conservative who converted to Catholicism in his teens and now writes for The New York Times. He infuriates many of my progressive friends, but I usually find his writings interesting and thought provoking even if I often disagree with him.

This month, First Things has published his 2015 talk, “A Crisis of Conservative Catholicism,” which is a thoughtful address to conservative Catholics in the era of Pope Francis. He is attempting to help conservatives cope with the changes happening in the church today.

President Obama shakes hands with Pope Francis during their meeting at the Vatican, March 2014.

I hope I will be forgiven for entering this intraconservative conversation. Although no one today would label me a conservative, I was raised in the conservative church of the 1950s, entered a conservative Jesuit novitiate in 1962 before the Second Vatican Council, and had a very difficult time making the transition to the post-Vatican II church.

In short, I have some sympathy with what conservatives are experiencing today because I went through a similar experience in the late 1960s.

For another view, see “Ross Douthat’s Erasmus Lecture” by Michael Sean Winters, which I did not see until after I wrote this column

Click here to read the entire article.

Exit mobile version